World Ecitizens - Home Page


World Ecitizens

Gallery of Students' Work

World Ecitizens - Home Page
Thin Line

MirandaNet

EXPERIMENTAL RESERCH
“SIMULATION OF TORNADO-PROCESS”
Secondary school No. 1273
of South-Western Administrative Okrug,
City of Moscow

Authors    
Apalnov Vladimir 11 “V” Staff and Pupils of Form 7C Pol'skih Anna 10 “V”
Panyushkin Alexei 11 “V” Naumov Pavel 10 “V”
Kitaeva Masha 10 “V” Pyrkov Dmitriy 9 “V”
Kotenko Oleg 10 “A” Zhyravlev Evgeniy 9 “V”
Kalimylina Olga 10 “A”  
   
Supervisors  
Ustugina Galina, the Physics teacher  
Nikitina Svetlana, the Computer teacher  
  sch1273@yandex.ru

Tornado Simulation

Introduction

Tornado SimulationOne of the modern problems of mankind consists in existence of numerous tornadoes and hurricanes which bring tremendous material losses. They systematically take away a large number of number of human lives. It is known that tornadoes and hurricanes occur at regular intervals and bring destruction. But we do not know the date and the route of the next tornado or hurricane. In connection with the world-wide warm-up of the climate, the scientists expect that the number and the force of these natural phenomena will sharply grow up. Therefore, the solution of the problem associated with the forecast of hurricanes and tornadoes, if not with their control, will be exceptional for the whole mankind

Tornado SimulationEven the appearance of the approaching tornado horrifies man. And exposure to its impact is equivalent to the greatest and frequently irretrievable calamity. However, the human thought and the experience are not at a standstill. The thought is being developed and the experience is being gained which brings some results already now. This research is an attempt to suggest our tornado control version based on experimental data.

 

STATEMENT OF PROBLEM

The mass media regularly inform the reads about the hurricanes, whirlwinds,tornadoes which take place in various parts of the world. Such information is always accompanied with the description of the dramatic consequences of the element impact on the man and its habitat. Tornado SimulationThe access to the information contained in the Internet has made it possible to establish that the data on the atmospheric vortex phenomena are borrowed not only for evidences if the eyewitnesses but also from the study of atmospheric vortexes which reveals their new details. There is a lot of scientific publications. There are many theories devoted to vortex atmospheric processes, including space processes. All modern mathematical methods making use of computer simulation of the processes are attracted. The study of the history of this problem shows that the mankind has been endeavouring to understand the nature of these phenomena for hundreds of years. Even Albert Einstein was not indifferent to this problem. We know his interpretation of the behaviour of the tea-leaves which are gathered in the centre of the glass with the tea. After the tea is no more stirred up with a tea-spoon in the glass, the rotary motion of the liquid is slowed down and the tea-leaves are gathered in the centre of the glass by the currents which are ascending in the centre and descending on the periphery. The analysis of the tiny but very representative information available on the whirlwinds, hurricanes and tornadoes prompts the following approach to this problem. First, it is necessary to make attempts at simulation of the vortex origination conditions in the laboratory. The laboratory model will help to make the initial evident observations. Then, the explanation of the processes which take place should be suggested. And finally, if possible, it is necessary to suggest the ways for solution of the problem of existence of the hurricanes, whirlwinds and tornadoes.

Let us stress the following aspects of the problem:

  1. The air currents in the tornado are divided into two parts: ascending air currents in the centre and descending air currents on the periphery.
  2. Both the central air current and the peripheral air current execute a spiral motion.
  3. The objects falling into the zone of the central air current which is termed the “trunk” are dynamically captured and transferred into the upper layers of the atmosphere. Later on, these objects, e.g. fish or coins, fall on the ground far beyond the tornado limits.
  4. More massive bodies, such as bridges and the like, experience a similar impact.
  5. Tornado offers a dynamic impact on all encountered structures and objects which are destroyed and on the creatures which are killed.

The first four aspects will be simulated, observed and analysed in the laboratory with the use of an experimental model. The fifth aspect makes ground for our proposals on its exclusion or lowering of the losses caused by the tornado.

Let us suppose that the liquid medium will simulate the atmospheric vortex phenomenon with the accuracy for our research. We understand that the formation, movement and existence of the tornado are supported by the atmospheric phenomena associated with the evaporation of the liquid from seas, rivers and oceans, convection of the warm and cold air masses, condensation of the vapour and precipitation of the condensate in the form of the rain or hail, and other processes and phenomena. We make use of an external device which creates and maintains the rotary motion of the liquid, thereby simulating all factors supporting the tornado. We suppose that this approximation is admissible for our experimental model.

Our observation results

Tornado SimulationFor observation of the vortex, common drinking water used as the medium where in the vortex is formed. A glass jar was filled with water to ¾ its capacity ( Fig.1, c). The activator (Fig.1, b) was screwed into the device (Fig.1, a) which imparted the rotation at a speed of 980 r/m with the power of 1.5W

 

 

 

 

 

 

Fig. 2

Tornado SimulationVarious bodies were placed into the jar with water (Fig.2). The motion of these bodies in water facilitated the observation of the water currents.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Fig. 3.

Tornado Simulation Fig.3a Tornado Simulation Fig.3bTornado Simulation Fig.3c

Fig.3 Successive moments of location of bodies submerged in water. Water is subjected to force clockwise rotation by activator (top view)

In response to the rotary water current, the bodies submerged into the jar with water are not only revolved together with water but are also separated from the bottom and raised by the water currents to the level of activator. After the bodies reach the upper layer of water, they are thrown together with the liquid to the wall of the glass jar, then go down to the bottom along the external spiral, and again move upward towards the activator along the internal spiral of a less curvature.

Fig. 4.

Tornado Simulation Fig.

4a               Tornado Simulation Fig.4b

Fig.4. Tea-leaf (a) and millet (b) motion in glass jars with rotary liquid

The steady-state motion of the-leaves in Fig. 4 (a) demonstrates the spiral ascending motion of the liquid in the central part of the vessel and spiral of the liquid on the periphery, near the walls of the vessel. It is important to stress the central column is not vertical. It looks like a spring which experiences additional oscillations and rotation near the axis of rotation of the activator. The millet in Fig. 4 (b) demonstrates the motion of the liquid under the effect of the cone shaped activator at the initial stage when the liquid ascending currents have been only formed.

Fig.5.

Tornado Simulation Fig.5a Tornado Simulation Fig.5b Tornado Simulation Fig.5c

Fig.5. Motion of hollow aluminium cup loaded with mincing machine cutter under effect of liquid rotary currents

It is shown in Fig. 5 that in the process of accumulation of the energy of rotation of the liquid and energy of the ascending and descending currents, a rather massive steel body resting on the aluminium support separates from the bottom of the vessel and starts to execute circular motion.

The edge of the system of two bodies located close to the centre is raised towards the ascending currents, while the edge close to the wall of the vessel is held down. Apart from being one more confirmation of existence of central ascending current and peripheral descending current, the figure the effect of the build-up (accumulation) of the energy of the source of rotation in the energy of liquid rotation.

Watching a usual picture of existence of the central ascending spiral current of the liquid, we should bear in mind that the cone-shaped concentration of the grains in the centre of the vessel is also indicative of the peculiarities involved in liquid motion in the central near-bottom part of the vessel. This effect explained by Einstein is well known as behaviour of the tea is no more stirred up by the tea-leaves which are gathered in the centre of the glass after the tea is no more stirred up the-spoon. Such behaviour is explained just by the existence of the central ascending spiral current and peripheral descending spiral current just in the whirling liquid. Besides, one more phenomenon has been noticed in the part in the result of careful examination of the liquid motion. A tread-like "trunk" which is formed by a system of the bubbles and cavities interconnected into a common thread extends from the activator to the centre of the vessel.

As it is illustrated in Fig. 6 (a, b, c) , this thread looks like a twisted spiral which constantly experiences of the "trunk" formation and existence has proved that the "trunk" is produced by the activator. After removal of the activator, the "trunk" is preserved until the near-surface funnel remains deep. In the course of disappearance of the funnel, the "trunk" separates from the central near-bottom part of the vessel, rises, and rather quickly disappears.

Tornado Simulation Fig 7a Tornado Simulation Fig 7b

Fig.7. "Trunk" in dynamics of termination of liquid rotary motion

A" clear" view of the "trunk" is illustrated in Fig.7. At first ,when the activator operates, the air cavity under the activator surface has a thread-like "trunk" extending to the bottom of the vessel. By selection of the proper lighting, the "trunk" is visually distinguished from the liquid transparent medium. Removal of the activator (Fig.7,b) results in the reduction of the funnel depth and in separation of the "trunk" from the bottom of the vessel. Further existence of the "trunk" rapidly terminates in the course of the decrease of the rotary energy of the liquid.

The existence of the ''trunk'' together with spiral central ascending and spiral peripheral descending currents of the rotary liquid gives an idea that this ''trunk'' is analogous to the ''trunk'' of the tornado which brings many troubles. If this is true, let us true to solve the problem of tornado control.

Check of hypothesis

Tornado SimulationIt follows from obtained experimental materials that the source of the energy of rotation, irrespective of its nature, transmits its energy to the rotary motion of the liquid. All energy accumulated in the descending current of the rotary motion of the liquid. All energy accumulated in the descending current of the rotary liquid is concentrated in the central ascending current of the same liquid. It is worth while mentioning that the energy of the source of the rotary motion of the liquid is accumulated in this liquid. As a result , all energy accumulated by the liquid is transported upwards by the central ''trunk'', which derives the energy from the lower layers of the liquid. Then, it is reasonable to interrupt this energy flow from the lower layers by any means.

It is shown in Fig.8 that a body with the periodically located holes is placed at the bottom of the vessel. It is assumed that active interaction of the rotary energy of these layers. The photo in Fig. 8 (a) taken by a conventional method shows that there is no ''trunk'' and no bubble under the activator. To make sure of this fact, the photo has been taken with the use of special lighting (Fig.8b). It is seen that liquid currents move upwards from the body in a chaotic manner. This is evidenced by the traces of the micro bubbles recorded by the camera. The enlarged view of this picture illustrated in Fig. 8 (c) once more proves the destruction of the conditions of formation of the tornado ''trunk''.

 

Fig.8. State of rotary liquid in presence of volumetric shaped body at vessel bottom

CONCLUSION

  1. For origination of rotary motion of the liquid and evidently gaseous medium, a source of energy of this rotation should be available in the upper layers of the liquid or atmosphere.
  2. In the process of the rotary motion, the medium gradually accumulates the energy of source &of this rotation.
  3. The energy of rotation of the medium is divided into to two main parts: the energy of the descending current and the energy of the ascending current of the movable medium. The energy of motion of the peripheral part of the medium is concentrated into the energy of motion of the central part. That’s why the central part of the tornado – the “trunk” possesses such a violent destructive force.
  4. Since the “trunk” energy by the process of accumulation of the energy of motion of the peripheral parts of the tornado which rush towards the centre on the level, i.e. to destroy the condition motion of the near-surface parts of medium towards the centre.
  5. We have suggested one version of such dissipation of energy with the use of a massive body with periodically located holes. As a matter of fact, such body considerably affects the origination of the tornado and doesn’t allow its formation.
  6. Probably, the construction of obstacles similar to the obstacle described in the present research work will put an end of the “tornado route” in the USA.

Back to the top

Back

Top